top of page
Search

Is Digital Writing the Final Resting Place of Connection?

Updated: Oct 12, 2024

Every day, when we interact with fellow human beings, we are improvisors. We are given prompts by the senses; the smell of grandma's fresh baked snickerdoodles, the taste cinnamon spice sticking to the roof of your mouth, as those warm cookies disintegrate. The cracks in the cold kitchen tile engulfing the pad of your foot, as you look into her gently aging eyes, and embrace the soft cotton of her red gingham apron.

ree

Then you hear the inevitable question: "How are you?"


In that moment, there are infinite choices of how to react to that stimulus. Some are so outlandish that our consciousness doesn't acknowledge them. For example, you may not choose to climb onto the kitchen countertop and do your best rendition of an irish jig in that moment. But you could. Technically speaking.


Alas, instead your mind makes a seemingly instantaneous decision between a few narrowed down choices, reached by almost infinite amounts of personal and social context. Firing synapses in the prefrontal cortex give way in the fraction of a second to a complete environmental analysis, followed by a responsive action. If there is a crowd of cousins also trying to hug grandma, you may stick to a simple "I'm fine, how are you?" If it is just the two of you, you may elaborate with a highlight from your week, month, year. If you're comfortable with each other and something is on your mind, you may use the question as a catalyst to air a grievance, or seek advice. If you're not comfortable with each other, you may lie. Using even more imagination.


As strange as it may seem, despite the spontaneity with which you may recieve a text or email notification on your phone or computer. The spontaneity of this imagined scenario; this instant application of imagination, improvisation, creativity, rarely exists in a digital communication space. There are so many variables communicators online can't see. They can't see what kind of day each other is having. They can't hear each other's voices. They don't know how long their digital correspondent takes to type messages. They may not even know each other's faces. People online can give themselves infinite amounts of time and space to curate their image and response to thier liking, if they so desire. They will have their pick of excuses for their delayed reply. And the other party's interpretation of truth is crucially limited by a lack of percieved tone, subtextual nature. Without the sponatneity of reaction to stimuli, can digital communication alone truly foster human connection? The imagery of my grandmother, paired with a photo of a heart-shaped cookie cutter, in a pile of cinnamon, might have evoked an emotional reaction. But, is it the same as being there? Seeing and hearing her? How do we fill in those gaps in digital communication accurately? How important is it to unplug, and "revert back" to previously concieved notions of language, fostered with in-person interactions?

 
 
 

2 Comments


sidney.parker
Sep 23, 2024

I really like your point about the lack of spontaneity a digital writing and communication platform projects. I especially resonated with the text message example. It is so easy to reply almost automatically or without a filter to verbal in person conversations, but digital texts allow for the second guessing of any response, even before you hit send. This allows them to be different, in whatever way that may be. I think this an important distinguishing fact about digital communication and something I don't know if it is good or bad, but just simply is.

Like

rescolby
Sep 19, 2024

Good point about the crisis of collapsed context that writing online brings. I do think that there are specific cases where writing online could bring two specific people closer. However, thus also means that you're specifically writing to one person and that person is writing specifically to you throughout a more prolonged period of time. I always grow frustrated with Facebook because of the collapse of the social context. As I befriend more academic, my posts just become about professional promotion. I can never honestly post about having a bad day, which makes me feel unheard emotionally. Then I just avoid Facebook entirely, which is also not a great response. In any case, you bring up some of these great…

Like
bottom of page